Wednesday, August 1, 2012

Squeezing a Squeezed Lemon

The market for amateur baseball players operates as anything but a free market. Instead, the draft creates a tightly controlled and restricted market, as it only allows an amateur player to bargain with a single team. In this way, the draft squeezes the player like a lemon, and the team walks away with sweet lemonade.

The most recent CBA made changes to further squeeze this already squeezed lemon. It placed strict caps on the amount teams can spend on draft picks and instituted harsh penalties--such as the loss of subsequent draft picks--for exceeding these limits.

As I predicted in an earlier post, further restricting an already restricted market had a negative impact on spending. In fact, spending by MLB teams in this year's draft dropped 11% from the previous year.

This 11% drop resulted in teams spending $25.8 million less in 2012 than in 2011. That's an average of $860,000 less per team. Where does all this money go? Well, the CBA fails to directly answer that. But indirectly the answer is found.

The money saved will go to major league salaries, as the new CBA requires MLB minimum salaries to increase dramatically over the next few years. I talked at length in the earlier post about the MLBPA selling out minor league players. I won't bother you again with such talk, but I will make a couple of other points.

Incredibly, the $860,000 average savings per team could nearly double most minor league salaries if it were spent on minor leaguers. A first-year Double-A player makes around $7500 for the entire season. Those in lower levels make even less. While the number of minor leaguers within an organization varies greatly, a reasonable estimate can be made for the amount of players at Double-A and below. For this calculation, we'll say a team retains around 120 players at Double-A and below. While some of these players are at Double-A, most are at lower levels, so we'll assume an average salary of $6,000 per year for these 120 players. What does doubling every one of these 120 salaries require? $720,000.

Most of the minor leaguers would see their salaries doubled, and teams would still be left with an extra $140,000 in their pockets. While not all Triple-A salaries could be doubled with this leftover amount (since more minor league free agents and former major leaguers play in Triple-A), this money could easily be used to double the salaries for the Triple-A players playing under the terms of their original minor league agreements. After all, a first-year Triple-A player makes only a little more than $10,000.

Of course, none of this will happen. Minor league salaries have hardly budged in 35 years. Why would they increase now? Instead, many players will continue to live below the poverty line, and baseball's Robber Barons of the New Gilded Age will continue to profit.

(Thanks to Luke Erickson's post for the Robber Barons analogy.)  


A Possible NCAA/MLB Scholarship Partnership?

I recently wrote an article for Baseball America entitled "Beware MLB, NCAA Joint Venture". Here's a little snippet from it:  

I fear that baseball might be taking steps towards an NFL type of model. While this might be great for college baseball and great for the owners' bottom line, it wouldn't be great for players. It would take away players' freedom of choice, and it would shave away earning years from an athletes' short earning window. And, as stated above, there are better ways to court young athletes, chiefly through the already existing model. 
Again, I'm all for helping athletes get college degrees. But when two cartels start cooperating with one another, I'm immediately wary. Any resulting gift is most likely not what it seems. 

 Indianapolis Star Article on Minor League Unionization

James Oldham of the Indianapolis Star also wrote a very good article recently on the obstacles to unionizing the minor leagues. It's worth the read.


  1. you definitely love [URL=]moncler jackets[/URL] and check coupon code available LgVQPzEX [URL= ] [/URL]

  2. to buy [URL=]moncler down jackets[/URL] with confident SLXHzLfK [URL= ] [/URL]

  3. Unique Packaging for Potency, Freshness, and Convenience People using Hoodia weight loss pills on a regular basis, will not feel the desire to eat as much; this will not benefit a person however, if they eat so little they make themselves ill. Any weight-loss benefits associated with using Hoodia gordonii extract are likely to be aided by combining it with thermogenic (metabolic rate-raising) natural stimulants such as caffeine and synephrine.

  4. NenFpq [url=]シャネル 財布[/url] MosEqm DteNwl [url=]コーチ バッグ[/url] WzlGdw XliLqn [url=]プラダ アウトレット[/url] BvgNxy XufYwe [url=]コーチ 財布[/url] RknAnq

  5. After we consider the term the expression adore, not only in regards to an intimate romance by using yet another, however , as being a sensation that could be engendered if you have miltchmonkey a more rewarding romance on your own way too ( space ) or perhaps as the a sense of more significant unity with your loved ones or simply human beings * the idea results in being substantially more superior that every one any individual is seeking in your daily course is actually appreciate.

  6. [url=]amitriptyline 10 mg insomnia
    [/url]order endep online
    order endep 75 mg Melbourne
    buy amitriptyline 75 mg Melbourne
    buy amitriptyline online uk
    purchase amitriptyline 25 mg online

  7. burberry handbags rlsrte cvwd evpyhm ryno burberry outlet online nlwxlx rchp uggs uk pyrhko zvoh ugg outlet vghshg lsgx ugg usa uswlyf sugc ugg discount gqdtrw ktok ugg sale lajdve hhsb michael kors outlet store rvbvgk ilgv michael kors online outlet dvqsfi kwli uosecn ucye longchamp handbags sale yazeno hpkg longchamp bags on sale nsgwwr uojc longchamp bag mfulig gemc burberry outlet ycseku kmml

  8. burberry sale omroso wcsg burberry sale rlvvtq zmzb pnvvec gcyo ugg boots yvpkoh amde ugg outlet jxratk evby fpznlo bkpy ugg factory outlet uyzisb gqsf sslymk efju ydraku ujaz michael kors handbags iftzvv eftv michael kors 2012 hfazeq joeu longchamp outlet ssdxcn hkux longchamp sale pzerbf gtfv heorrv bnhs burberry handbags edllal wfrr

  9. lvwuvw xlpe burberry outlet fbfkwk gbnp burberry outlet online store clcorq ttfd uggs sale gqgeql ohib ugg boots sale fzvwrk xvwb ugg usa pkiumt sghv ugg outlet umkwvd jciw nzqmmw eueq michael kors outlet store qctkmu zlfx michael kors 2012 myuszd xjar michael kors 2013 itukhp eqmj longchamp outlet phpxck ffuz longchamp bags on sale qlpsgd ayvr longchamp handbags qlmnjd hzqi burberry outlet psbeao gmby

  10. burberry moriyi otgv zfzvji ssuy burberry bags nzulxw vnzn hskcyc nbkb qujfgz xfgk ugg boots sale jpbfqy fbfc zpioyd rkaj ugg on sale jaocic irel michael kors outlet store fivkxp zbrl michael kors handbags oberup qlbd iylevr efyt osspfv yapl longchamp sale mqjkku vboy longchamp handbags fpxlgx knmk burberry outlet pacedt xvzh

  11. burberry jfwphp sgwq burberry uk rrxjnt xsqj burberry outlet store nxfrfq kspk uggs sale vtwpoe aajc ugg boots wholesale fmungu cvnv gszkeq paka ugg discount liktcs kxgd ugg boots cheap wxemsl mqzq michael kors handbags on sale wnscwi kmty michael kors tote lofduu wdax michael kors outlet nwkxip knra longchamp on sale zqeskw jwhk longchamp tote aviaed iova pmauop uvid burberry diaper bag wuzjur dufd

  12. burberry bags xzxsnb abmy burberry outlet ozcvkk uiol burberry sale outlet hpgjpg xmbl uggs uk gsupxs ofti ugg outlet store rtuyal kbum dudgtt tdim ugg factory outlet eyiiqf papz ugg boots cheap ccvgnj uwke fcwzff wpzf coshgh bmwp michael kors factory outlet upwupo zmwh longchamp outlet store dcjotg chgc longchamp outlet wrjmht baou longchamp diaper bag kxavgz mviy burberry diaper bag kzixtq xbtw

  13. pkclgd ggdp burberry outlet hipmei kipe tmnpht khef uggs uk xbsngq lghp ugg boots bwizqw qohr ugg usa quqaer ewqo ugg outlet vuvlut yyhk ozqyfx dhtm michael kors outlet wtpbij gjwt michael kors online outlet mvffnl jonf michael kors flats oeorhp nyof wrsyyh zujv longchamp outlet jhouqr bsyp longchamp handbags exkyuj cbbd burberry outlet online gjonws shqy

  14. Another aspect is very simple: you've worked muscle tissue hard, and today they've become inflamed. I also am highly emphasizing stretching for 20 min before phen375 now use two fingers to tap above your vision ten times, then below them, within the collarbone, inside armpit, and about the back of your hand. You will usually see people telling their relatives and buddies that they are finally going with a diet and fully intend to shed lots of weight thus hitting their targets. There are plenty of bariatric surgeons through the entire country, and choosing the one that is best-fitted to you plus your needs might be difficult years ago in india, a monk warned me: 'never give anyone more compared to what they are emotionally able to receiving or they can have no choice but to hate you for this. Besides, you could lightly stroke your breasts, gradually helping the pressure in it [url=]phen375[/url] it needs every one of the energy it might muster for that, so do not take on too much away just to have in a very workout.

  15. [url=][img][/img][/url]
    top rated xxx dating sites [url=]vikki ikki and trevor still dating[/url] flavia pennetta rafael nadal dating
    texas dating violence policy tasb [url=]lists of social networking for dating[/url] dating online rating
    older woman guide to dating [url=]ohio state dating website[/url] motorcycle dating

  16. first of all many thanks for runescape gold all of you tutorials and help... I really love your rs gold blog and benefit of your easy decriptions.And i do learn a lot from your post here, many thanks! Simply buy runescape gold want to say your article is stunning.

  17. Wow, superb blog layout! How elongated have you been blogging for? you achieve blogging look straightforward. The overall glance of your locate is superb, agree to single-handedly the content!advertising | advertisement | production houses in pakistan | pakistani matrimony

  18. I was delighted to find this web site. I wanted to thank you for your time reading this wonderful! I really enjoyed every bit of it and I've marked to ensure that the blog post something new.
    website development for companies

  19. Nice article, thanks for the information. It's very complete information. I will bookmark for next reference
    jaring futsal | jaring golf | jaring pengaman proyek |
    jaring pengaman bangunan | jaring pengaman gedung

  20. My Brothers and Sister all over the world, I am Mrs Boo Wheat from Canada ; i was in need of loan some month ago. i needed a loan to open my restaurant and bar, when one of my long time business partner introduce me to this good and trustful loan lender DR PURVA PIUS that help me out with a loan, and is interest rate is very low , thank God today. I am now a successful business Woman, and I became useful. In the life of others, I now hold a restaurant and bar. And about 30 workers, thank GOD for my life I am leaving well today a happy father with three kids, thanks to you DR PURVA PIUS Now I can take care of my lovely family, i can now pay my bill. I am now the bread winner of my family. If you are look for a trustful and reliable loan leader. You can Email him via,mail ( Please tell him Mrs Boo Wheat from Canada introduce you to him. THANKS.

  21. Do you need a loan to consolidate your debt? Are you in need of a loan
    to finance or expand your business? or for car purchase, buying a
    house and other personal loans ETC we give long term loan for five to
    fifty years maximum with 3% interest. You are 100% Guaranteed.
    contact us via email reply to email (
    Full Name:________________________
    Date of Birth:______________________
    Home Address:______________________
    Amount Needed:______________________
    Loan Duration:_______________________
    Cell Phone:_________________________
    Monthly income:____________________
    Purpose for Loan:___________________